Clare no events posted in last week
Interested in maladministration. Estd. 2005
RTEs Sarah McInerney ? Fianna Fail supporter? Anthony
Joe Duffy is dishonest and untrustworthy Anthony
Robert Watt complaint: Time for decision by SIPO Anthony
RTE in breach of its own editorial principles Anthony
Waiting for SIPO Anthony Public Inquiry >>
A Blog About Human Rights
UN human rights chief calls for priority action ahead of climate summit Sat Oct 30, 2021 17:18 | Human Rights
5 Year Anniversary Of Kem Ley?s Death Sun Jul 11, 2021 12:34 | Human Rights
Poor Living Conditions for Migrants in Southern Italy Mon Jan 18, 2021 10:14 | Human Rights
Right to Water Mon Aug 03, 2020 19:13 | Human Rights
Human Rights Fri Mar 20, 2020 16:33 | Human Rights Human Rights in Ireland >>
Fifty Ways to Leave the European Convention on Human Rights Fri Apr 19, 2024 17:28 | Dr David McGrogan Rishi Sunak has once again been dropping hints about leaving the European Convention on Human Rights. This is not credible, says Dr David McGrogan: such a feat would require a Government far more serious than this one.
The post Fifty Ways to Leave the European Convention on Human Rights appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Pupil Suspensions Reach Record High as Experts Blame Effect of Lockdowns on Behaviour Fri Apr 19, 2024 15:30 | Will Jones The number of pupils suspended from school has reached a record high as experts warn that bad behaviour has increased as a result of lockdown school closures.
The post Pupil Suspensions Reach Record High as Experts Blame Effect of Lockdowns on Behaviour appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Up to Half of Excess Deaths in U.S. Nursing Homes Were Due to Lockdowns and Mitigation Measures Fri Apr 19, 2024 13:19 | Will Jones Up to half of excess deaths in American nursing homes were due to the impact of lockdowns and mitigation measures on frail residents rather than the virus, according to new analysis.
The post Up to Half of Excess Deaths in U.S. Nursing Homes Were Due to Lockdowns and Mitigation Measures appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Woke Activists Need to Read Their David Hume Fri Apr 19, 2024 11:16 | Dr James Allan The great Scottish Enlightenment philosopher David Hume would have some things to teach today's woke activists, says Prof James Allan: about a mind-independent reality that has no truck with claims of 'my truth'.
The post Woke Activists Need to Read Their David Hume appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Farmers? Biggest Problems are Green Ideologues, not Climate Change Fri Apr 19, 2024 09:00 | Ben Pile It's been a wet winter and this is bad news for farmers, says Ben Pile. But with agricultural yields increasing sharply over recent decades, there's no reason to link it to climate change or start catostrophising about it.
The post Farmers? Biggest Problems are Green Ideologues, not Climate Change appeared first on The Daily Sceptic. Lockdown Skeptics >>
Voltaire, international edition
The cost of war, by Manlio Dinucci Wed Apr 17, 2024 04:12 | en
Angela Merkel and François Hollande's crime against peace, by Thierry Meyssan Tue Apr 16, 2024 06:58 | en
Iranian response to attack on its consulate in Damascus could lead to wider warf... Fri Apr 12, 2024 13:36 | en
Is the possibility of a World War real?, by Serge Marchand , Thierry Meyssan Tue Apr 09, 2024 08:06 | en
Netanyahu's Masada syndrome and the UN report by Francesca Albanese, by Alfredo ... Sun Apr 07, 2024 07:53 | en Voltaire Network >>
|
Court Report Shannon Banner Drop
clare |
anti-war / imperialism |
news report
Monday September 19, 2005 16:38 by Court Reporter
Special sitting Sunday morning for activists
The four peace activists who were arrested at Shannon yesterday afternoon, were held overnight in Shannon Garda Station for a special sitting of the District Court in Ennis this morning. The state asked for very strict bail conditions, and for once, Judge Mangan did not grant the State's wishes. Four peace activists were arrested at Shannon airport yesterday afternoon.
Two of them had taken part in dropping several banners (two of them very large) from the balcony at the front of the terminal while dressed as Guantanamo prisoners and US soldiers.
Two other people who were taking photographs and video footage from the car park were also arrested and had their cameras seized.
They were held in the Garda station and brought to court at 11am this morning (Sunday)
Here is a summary based on notes of Indy's court reporters.
Court Report
Shannon District Court
Ennis Court House
Sunday 18th September 2005.
Prosecution: Inspector Tom Kennedy
Defendants:
Conor Cregan
Niall Harnett
Margaret Liddy
St.John O'Sullivan
Counsel:
Mr. Cregan is defending himself
Ted McCarthy represented the others.
Judge Joseph Mangan presiding.
Evidence was given by Garda Brian Doherty of Shannon Garda Station that he arrested Margaret Liddy at Shannon airport and charged her under Section 33 of the Air Transport and Navigation Act 1988.
Defending solictor, Ted McCarthy pointed out that he had not been given a true copy of the charge sheet and this was remedied.
Garda Doherty gave evidence of arresting St. John O'Donovan at 16:05 at Shannon airport under the same section.
Sgt David Condren of Shannon Garda Station gave evidence of arresting Niall Harnett at Shannon Airport at 3.10pm and charging him under the same section as the others.
Sgt Condron said that Mr. Harnett was cautioned and then replied as follows :
"I came to Shannon as part of a peaceful protest to highlight the ongoing use of Shannon Airport as a U.S. Military Airbase, to highlight the facilitation here of CIA torture jets, and to highlight the deal done by Minister for Injustice Michael McDowell with the CIA, giving them carte blanche interrogation rights in this country. I made this peaceful protest under Section 40 of the Irish Constitution and I expect those rights to be respected and vindicated by the law enforcers of this country."
The Sgt then gave evidence of arresting Conor Cregan at 3.20pm at Shannon airport, and charging him under s.33 of the same act.
In reply to charge and caution, he said Mr. Cregan said "My name is Conor Cregan and I engaged in peaceful protest at Shannon Airport today to highlight the fact that the Irish Government is facilitating rendition, or what is known as rendition, which means to take prisoners for torture, through Shannon Airport, by the CIA, as is against everything I stand for, and what I believe this country stands fo. I went to Shannon Airport to protest peacefully without arms and assemble with other peace activists as is my right as laid down by Bunreacht na hEireann, the Constitution of Ireland. I was motivated to do this by the Nuremberg Accords, the Geneva Conventiona and the United Nations Charter. I stand firm with the workers of Shannon Airport in their plight. The airport is in a bad situation in terms of business through the airport but i can only condone ethical business, and sanctity of life, rights and humna dignity should be acknowledged at all times at Shannon Airport. This is not a political statement. This is how I feel. Thank you" (the Sgt initiallty tried to simply hand a note of this to the Judge rather than read it out, but the judge directed him to read it)
Mr. Cregan said that he had not been served with a true copy of the charge sheet as the name was missing. The judge was rather annoyed at the prosecution for this and made them amend all charge sheets.
Mr. Cregan asked that the court order the state to secure all evidence, and to furnish him with copies of all evidence, statements, photos, dictaphones, video tapes whether from CCTV or not.
The judge granted the order.
Inspector Kennedy said that the state was not objecting to bail for any of the four persons, but sought the following conditions :-
- that they reside at the addresses given at time of arrest
-that they sign on at their local Garda Station every day between 4pm and 6pm.
-that they are excluded from Shannon Airport and their environs, as they have no business being there. They are not employed there.
-that the state has liberty to re-enter the charges at 24 hours notice.
Mr. McCarthy said that his clients were not agreeable to the signing on agreements. That charges under S.33 were akin to the Public Order Act S.8, that his clients had no previous convictions, and that two of them were students who would be greatly inconvenienced by the restrictions, which were over the top, once the Garda have been satisfied to their details.
Judge : Why does the State feel that these restrictions are required?
Inspector Kennedy :
It's eh, because... It's a control mechanism for the state, ... to monitor their activities and movements.
Judge: Can you give me a very brief resume of the allegations against them?
Inspector : Mr. Cregan and Mr. Harnett went upstairs to the balcony, the outdoor balcony at Shannon, next to the cafe. They rolled out banners, which we would term, eh... Anti war... anti US banners.
When the Airport police went there, they were prevented from removing the banners by Mr Cregan and Mr. Harnett. Airport Police Sgt brian Casey requested them to do this.
Regarding Ms Liddy and Mr. O'Donovan, they were at the airport and were interviewed by the Airport Police. Their names and addresses were sought. They refused to comply fully.
Judge: in what way did Mr. Cregan and Mr. Harnett impede?
Inspector: They held the door closed, and prevented the airport police from accessing the balcony.
[The Inspector also made allegations of behaviour, about which no charge had been made, and we got the impression that reporting retrictions may apply in those circumstances]
Ted McCarthy (Defense) : Firstly, the Inspector
cannot refer to potential charges not before the court. I would take issue that he says that my clients have no business being at the airport. They were in a public area, an area that the public are entitled to enter.
Judge: I'll rise for five minutes to allow you to discuss this with the inspector, and you may reach an agreement
When court resumed, the Inspector said that the State's postition had not changed.
The defence (jointly agreed postion) argued that this was strying into preventative justice, which is not provided for in Irish Law. That the defendant's were entitled to be in Shannon Airport for various reasons, not simply boarding a flight and leaving.
That the charge was a lesser charge than a public order charge, particularly the alleged failure to provide details of identity above and beyond the name and address. That the conditions were onerous.
That it is already a standard condition of bail that the bailee agrees not to commit an offence and to be of good behaviour.
That the other standard conditions of bail, to ensure court appearance, and prevent interference with witnesses, were not an issue, as there was no suggestion that the defendants would not appear in court, or interfere with witnesses.
That the state contends that some of them unfurled a banner expressing a view held by them, and impeded an Airport officer in removing the banner, while others are in court charged with failure to give details of identity.
But they DID give their names and addresses when asked, and the state has said that it is happy that those details are correct.
judge : When did the state become satisfied with the details.
Inspector: late yesterday evening
Mr. McCarthy: they volunteered this at first instance. When i visited them in Shannon Garda Station yesterday evening, before they had been charged, the state was already satisfied with those details. My clients did nothing to mislead anyone at any time.
They didn't have proof of ID.
pictures to follow ----
The Judge ruled out the signing on order. and the exclusion order.
The defendants were told to apply for the return of any property not held as evidence.
In relation to cameras held by the accused at time of arrest the state said it wanted to send these to Dublin to be examined for evidence.
The defence expressed some concern about the fate of the tapes.
The Judge ruled that the accused could be present at Garda HQ when the videos are downloaded from their cameras to ensure that no improprieties occur.
Case was adjourned to 13th October. Bail at own bond. and the four were released, and met with a crowd of supporters.
|
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (18 of 18)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18Thanks CR and to the four activists! Nice one!!
A series of photos taken before and after the court sitting yesterday. All four were in good spirits despite spending 20 hours in Shannon Garda Station.
Conor arrives at court house
Margaret and St.John stepping out into the sunshine.
Photos of the photographers.
Mags and St. John stepping into Ennis sunshine
Niall and Conor greet some of their supporters on their way in to court
Hello peacniks!
Great courage. Great report. Great pictures.
Thank you everyone
Some of the supporters who made it out to court
So many supporters St.John's felt the need to block some of them out!
Hi all - excellent reporting and pics. Solidarity and hope to see you all in Shannon on Saturday.
Thanks very much to everyone, friends and strangers, who sent texts, phoned messages to the Garda station, posted comments and came to Ennis courthouse, some travelling long distances. Thanks to those who went shopping and cooked for us after the court.
Special thanks to Damien Moran who spread the word on our behalf.
Your support is uplifting, encouraging and greatly appreciated in the face of a State aggressively zealous in controlling dissent, denying legal protest and protecting the privacy of it's deals with war criminals and other low-lifes of their kind.
We just want to defend the peace.
I was unsure whether I was going to go to Shannon or not. But this great act and the States defiance of has tipped me over the edge and I'm definitely going down now. Great work to all involved. Conor Cregan's opening statement was superb.
... and give the message, TOGETHER.
Great work!!!!!
for the great pics.Now I know who to "terminate with extreme prejudice".
Mind the bathroom floor,bike and car brakes,etc,etc
Anti-war protestors due in court
Four anti-war protestors were arrested in Shannon on Saturday.
The protestors occupied a balcony area of the airport and refused access to members of the airport police.
Three men and one woman are being held in Shannon Garda Station and are expected to appear before a sitting of Ennis District Court at 11am this morning.
great action, keep it up. we are very proud of you
Brilliant work to all those involved.
What sort of a country is this where one cannot make a peaceful protest about a hugely serious humanitarian and political issue?
Is it now a crime to drop a banner in protest?
The State is trying its best to curb democracy. They took away our posters off the street, they jail us whenever they can, the police (a certain segment) brutalize and probably kill some of the country's citizens. The minister for justice keeps his head down and the police do an "independant" investigation. Dumphy was brilliant this morning on the case where the young Dublin man was supposed to have hanged himself. He came straight out and basically said that there was every chance that the death was probably murder at the hands of the police and that the "independant" investigation was a mockery. He is frustrated at the gardai and the justice dept. continually refusing to put a spokesperson on the show to represent their views. Are the people of Ireland not entitled to hear what they have to say??
In the name of democracy and sense the country is crying out for a totally independand ombudsman. McBrearty is going after the State with this aim in mind and will hopefully succeed.
The State and the Western World in genearl is trying to supress democracy. We must make sure they do not succeed.
See you all in Shannon!!
WELL DONE!!!
Great statements lads, wish I had been there to support ye all!
click on the link to go the court report for the Oct 13th court appearance.