Cops welcomed with smoke bombs and flares Dublin Pride 19:57 Jul 14 0 comments Gemma O'Doherty: The speech you never heard. I wonder why? 05:28 Jan 15 0 comments A Decade of Evidence Demonstrates The Dramatic Failure Of Globalisation 15:39 Aug 23 1 comments Thatcher's " blind eye" to paedophilia 15:27 Mar 12 0 comments Total Revolution. A new philosophy for the 21st century. 15:55 Nov 17 0 comments more >>Blog Feeds
Anti-EmpireNorth Korea Increases Aid to Russia, Mos... Tue Nov 19, 2024 12:29 | Marko Marjanovi? Trump Assembles a War Cabinet Sat Nov 16, 2024 10:29 | Marko Marjanovi? Slavgrinder Ramps Up Into Overdrive Tue Nov 12, 2024 10:29 | Marko Marjanovi? ?Existential? Culling to Continue on Com... Mon Nov 11, 2024 10:28 | Marko Marjanovi? US to Deploy Military Contractors to Ukr... Sun Nov 10, 2024 02:37 | Field Empty
Human Rights in IrelandPromoting Human Rights in Ireland
Lockdown Skeptics
J.K. Rowling Leads Backlash Against Sturgeon for Claiming There Was No Public Opposition to Gender S... Tue Dec 24, 2024 11:23 | Will Jones
Science Shock: CO2 is Good for the Planet, Peer-Reviewed Studies Suggest Tue Dec 24, 2024 09:00 | Chris Morrison
Whoever Rules Britain Is Going to Be Unpopular Tue Dec 24, 2024 07:00 | Noah Carl
News Round-Up Tue Dec 24, 2024 00:40 | Richard Eldred
Can Science Tell Us the Meaning of Life? Mon Dec 23, 2024 19:54 | Dr David Bell
Voltaire NetworkVoltaire, international editionVoltaire, International Newsletter N?113 Fri Dec 20, 2024 10:42 | en Pentagon could create a second Kurdish state Fri Dec 20, 2024 10:31 | en How Washington and Ankara Changed the Regime in Damascus , by Thierry Meyssan Tue Dec 17, 2024 06:58 | en Statement by President Bashar al-Assad on the Circumstances Leading to his Depar... Mon Dec 16, 2024 13:26 | en Voltaire, International Newsletter N?112 Fri Dec 13, 2024 15:34 | en |
Irish International Soccer in Decline
national |
miscellaneous |
feature
Sunday October 08, 2006 22:06 by jim travers
The FAI are about as capable of directing the interests of Irish international football as Eamonn Dunphy is of keeping quiet. After the Cyprus mauling the fans called for the sacking of Steve Staunton. The FAI got rid of Brian Kerr while Mick McCarty ran under the pressure of his failings. So is it time we forgot about blaming those the FAI appointed as international soccer managers and look towards the FAI as the continuing reasons for the decline in our interantion football team and the long departed good old days of glory? The appointment by the FAI of Steve Staunton as manager of the Republic of Ireland international football team has once again demonstrated the capability of those who walk the corridors of Merrion Square to professionally handle the responsibilities necessary for an international football team to progress on the international or world stage.
Let us be openly straight and honest about this current situation, the FAI are about as capable of directing the interests of Irish international football as Eamonn Dunphy is of keeping quiet and that is by no means of any disrespect to Eamonn Dunphy. Time and time again the FAI have made one debacle after another, as one crisis runs immediately into another and Irish soccer, be it at a national or international level, is once again placed under the microscope and seen for what it really is. Other links: A Clear Case of Off-Side | Red card to racism shown at Tolka Park | Roy Keane was right to speak out | Sam Maguire - Irelands most famous Protestant | Ireland v Israel | Israel v Zimbabwe | Opening up Croke Park | Will Handball Ever "Take" in Cooley? | Who Stole the Soul of Manchester United? The Charlton days gave us a belief that soccer was of the people and out of that belief the FAI sang all the way to the bank. What we now find is that the FAI have consistently time after time made controversial appointments and decisions without any professional standard of reasoning attached to its decisions. It is time the whole business of international football was taken out of the hands of the FAI in order to allow them to concentrate on the progression of junior and intermediate soccer in Ireland. When the association can prove to itself, the professional football players who wear their countries colours and the supporters who spend vast sums of money following their team, that they are ready to act as the representative body of Irish soccer, then and only then should the FAI be considered in having any association with international football.
The merging of the FAI and IFA would possibly lay to rest the public perception that the FAI is an association of people with personal vested interests over the interests of soccer at all levels throughout the country. The merging would allow a greater pool of players to be made available for selection and would give the international team a better chance of competing in major soccer tournaments. Most importantly it would help break down the barriers that have caused so much division in Northern Ireland for far too long. It would possibly find no support within Merrion Square as the power of the merry men is diluted by those coming onto the board from a foreign state. Look at it as simply as this, if a plumber went into an operating theatre and tried to tell the surgeon how to conduct an operation what do you think the surgeon would say or think about the situation? Once again just like the surgeon in the operating theatre the FAI try to secure the services of top class professional players to play under their commercial banner that is packaged as soccer, but support those services with a yellow pack money scrimping attitude. Why should players who play every week in the English premiership or First Division play on a team that has been provided with a yellow pack backup and support service by an association whose coffers will swell should that team show any progress. Roy Keane exposed the sham that is the FAI and it is the FAI and only the FAI who could appoint an individual, who despite all his enthusiasm in working for success of Irish soccer, is in reality currently not at an international football managerial stage to take on the task required of him.
I feel sorry for Steve Staunton for he is a nice guy with the interest of Irish soccer and its fans at heart, and it’s the shame of the FAI to have even considered appointing Steve at this stage in his football career. If their thoughts were for the building of a new squad for the future then the most logical decision would have been to either appoint an experienced manager or retain Brian Kerr as the Irish person capable of doing such a task. Let’s us not forget that Brian Kerr’s record as an international manager at this level is indeed very impressive. Luck did not go his way, but there again luck does not go the right way for some of the most successful teams in world soccer. Kerr was not given enough time to build a team for the future, just as Steve Staunton will be shown the same door when the big heads in FAI headquarters see the bank account remain the same and they come out with another Irish style lame duck excuse and apology for the decision they had to take “ in the interest of Irish soccer”.
The final decision will, in the long run prove to be the most costliest decision they have ever taken and will result in the association in the future (if they are still around) deciding to build a new stadium beyond the boundaries of the city where they can expand and grow their facilities in response to an ever growing population combined with their ever demanding need to provide all the services in one location, necessary to cater for such huge numbers of people converging into one area. Look at the mayhem and inconvenience that surrounds Croke Park every time a major event takes place. Look at how one section of the city has to come to a halt and how that halts ripple to every other part of the city. Our road infrastructure is not capable of handling or supporting either the vast numbers of vehicles converging on the city or the numbers of people congregating into one area. It is not fair on the people who reside in the immediate areas and it is definitely not fair on those who just need to commute or walk either for business or pleasure within our city. The new Lansdowne Road stadium will only add to the inconvenience to everybody, including the commuting fans as they clammer for available parking spaces or public transport facilities surrounding the stadium. |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (24 of 24)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24As a passionate and humiliated soccer fan i take great pleasure in opening up indymedia and reading a well argued and long overdue critique of the FAI. Like all soccer fans i cringed, cried and almost fell over with rage as i watched a footballing catastrophe yesterday evening.
Irish football is in a mess, as a teenager i watched and waited with anticipation the building of what was supposed to be Shamrock Rovers new stadium around the corner from my house in Tallaght. 8 years on, amongst a litany of corruption accusations, and blame games, it stands idle and derelict representing not only a community isolated and pissed upon by the irish state but the current state of irish soccer.
However, while we need a new and better organised instituiton of some sort to deal with the state of irish soccer, some blame has to rest with Staunton and the players. He should never have been appointed by those muppets in Merrion Square, lets take that for granted. But listening to his interviews and claims about building for the future many of us anticiapted the humilation that occured yesterday. It was quite obvious that he does not have belief in the irish players to perform. From the interviews i heard with Steve it sounded as if he knew we were going to lose, he spoke about not expecting too much, building for the future, how much of a great team Cyprus are ( ranked 103 in world rankings and included in a list of teams such as San Marino that ought in the future go through a preliminary tournament in order to get to the qualifiers).
Now any of us who played soccer at under 8;s , 10's , 15's etc know that if your manager does not believe in you then the team will not have any belief. However, and credit to Stan, and it may reflect what Kerr found as our manager, the refusal of the players themselves to take the international stage seriously is also a growing problem. Some commentators have argued that international football is dead, corporate clubs spoil their players, they live lavish lifestyles, earn grotesque amounts of money .. breeding footballers, like our youth into greedy, spoilt irresponsible brats with no alliegence to anyone except their bank managers.
Now, of course, i would not include the likes of Richard Dunne, Robbie Keane and duffers in that mix but it may be a factor.
Anyway, the core problem undoubtedly lies with the FAI , and i wait in vain and hope for the appointment of Roy Keane to the international stage, not only would he build, organise and get the best out of players he would take no shit from the gobshites currently in charge of Irish soccer.
If i cant play ball, its not my revolution!
I find it very difficult to blame Steve Staunton for last nights debacle.
Paddy Kenny has close to two months e3xperience in the Premiership
Steve Finnan has played in one of the most high octain Chamipons League Finals Ever
John O Shea has been playing Champions League for Years and Fergie continues to have faith in him
Richard Dunne was last years Player of the year at Man City
Andy O Brien should not be in the Iirsh team as he is not in Portsmouths first team
Aiden MCGeady is on top of his game at Celtic
Damien Duff has accrued total transfer fees of 23 Million over 2 moves
Kevin Kilbane has 10 yearsa experiences under his belt
Stephan Ireland New
Clinton Morrison has scored enough goals for Ireland to grab one last night
Robbie Keane Record Irish Goalscorer
With the exception of O Brien and Ireland, there is no excuse. The team last night disgraced Ireland and virtually spit on the tricolour. In the past 5 years we have taken on Cyprus on five occasions. In 2001 we beat them 4-0 on both occasions. Two years ago we dominated them at Lansdowne Road, and they were lucky to leave with only a 3-0 deficit. Last year we were as inept as we were last night, however Kerr had instilled some kind of defensive quality within the sde. However in one fell swoop we have let in 5 goal against what would be considered as an inferior side. Frankly it could have been so much worse. Konstantinou could have had five on a better day. Now that has noithing to do with the manager, and all to do with the team
Catalonia & Euskadi (Basque country) have just played their first international game of soccer at Barcelona's camp nou stadium which ended in a draw with 4 goals scored two of which went to each side. A crowd of 56,354 football fans left the stadium (& home to Barca football club) just short of 50% capacity but the messages were clear :-
* Basques & Katalanders like footie & deserve national teams coz they're nations.
* Katalanders play shite football without the Brazilian professional footballers. Until a future generation of Katalans is born to migrants & foreigners who are currently like this comment author excluded from playing footie or hurling indeed for Katalalaland - their games will only be worth going to for the flag waving nationalism..... Not that that isn't a fun thing.
I hope Ireland has got past the nationalism and sees soccer footie as a game to bring people together of all creeds, races, sexual orientation & worshipping prejudices. It is thus time we had more black lesbian atheist out & proud Irish players and I'm sure ye'll all agree.
Thanks for the great article.
I'm an anarchist living in the North, and am a passionate football supporter. I support Northern Ireland, and give a lot of credit to the IFA for their anti-racist and anti-sectarian initiatives. And the fact that NI is actually playing well makes life as a fan a whole lot easier.
I also support Republic of Ireland, and truly hope they can reclaim some lost dignity, turn things around, and get some victories.
As to a merger of the IFA and FAI, who knows? Some teams could thrive in an expanded pool, others would suffer. The fittest would survive (Go Cliftonville!). But on an international level, it works for rugby to field one team, so if it could be pitched to the fans in the right way, maybe. I'd hope for anything that draws people together rather than divides them, regardless of politics.
if you want to read about football, read the corporate media or watch tv. There's usually about 30-40% of most tabloids dedicated to such safe inanities to fill the pages and distract the masses from real world events (which there is surprisingly little coverage of)
There is a similarly disproportionate amount taken up in each news broadcast on RTE by football related shite when they should be using the time to cover more important topics or for more in depth coverage.
Sorry folks but It just really makes me mad these days when I see it.
We don't need this football soma crap cluttering up indymedia as well.
Hedgehog. The clue was in the title of the thread. If you didn't want to read about football, you shouldn't have opened the thread. I for one applaud the fact that you get ordinary people talking about such diverse issues here. I'm not sure how in tune with the masses you are but who do you think was making up the majority of viewers on Saturday night?
But the football coverage in the corporate media is just that - Corporate. Whats wrong with having an independant view of the game?
The team needs a radical overhaul! Staunton needs to get some good League of Ireland players and get them training with the Premiership players. When they are as fit as they can be, he should tell Duff and Keane and the other overpaid players they are on the bench for the match.
The problem is there is no commitment from these players. Hopefully a LoI player would appreciate the chance of playing at the top level and give their all.
It might also show Duff, Keana et al. where they are going wrong. If they go out on the pitch believing they only have to go through the motions, the team is going nowhere. That is what happened on Saturday and will happen again on Wednesday.
Bring on a bit of commitment!
Is it time for a rethink about letting soccer into Croke Park? In light of the frankly embarassing and inept performance by a number of professional sportsmen who were representing Ireland in Cyprus last week, a number of whom actually live in the country, is it not simply lowering the standard we expect of high quality sporting fixtures at Croke Park by permitting them the use of one of Europe's premier stadiums?
As someone delighted to see Ireland fail to qualify for the European Championships, loathing the FAI as much as the FAI loathes the GAA, perhaps it will assist those of us trying to encourage young people into playing sports not based on the key soccer principles of diving, hypocrisy, betrayl, greed and posing. Irish soccer is indeed in decline, long mayv it continue, and rapidly may it accelerate.
The author of the initial feature complains about the GAA not allowing soccer into Croke Park on a permanent basis, seemingly posessed of some curious notion of divine right to play in a stadium built by the most successful national amateur sporting organisation in the world, while the FAI Cup Final would draws a smaller crowd than the Ladies Football GAA final.
Meanwhile, COME ON YOU CZECHS.
"....is it not simply lowering the standard we expect of high quality sporting fixtures at Croke Park by permitting them the use of one of Europe's premier stadiums?"
Could be worse, they could be opening it up for something like the car boot sale recently held in Casement Park. All the things your party couldn't sell on Ebay. Although Staunton might need a blanket to hide under on Wednesday.
Sorry folks but It just really makes me mad these days when I see it. We don't need this football soma crap cluttering up indymedia as well.
This sort of view you have of the sheepish 'masses' really is patronising in the highest order. As if the only sector of society to have a critical faculty towards the institutions and cultural products of capitalism are people like yourself. Brave Indymedia readers should know better than allowing forms of 'soma crap' like football to clutter the site. Its amazing how hamstung left wing critiques becomes because of such attitudes.
Funny isn't it how one of the most dynamic, successful and long lasting campaigns against corporate media lies has been carried out by communities in Liverpool in the wake of the Sun's scurrilous allegations placing the responsiblity for Hillsborough on the back of tealeafing and drunk scouse stereotypes.
http://www.anfieldroad.com/news/comments_and_quotes/200....html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hillsborough_disaster#The_...paper
http://slash.autonomedia.org/analysis/02/07/14/2328225....shtml
http://libcom.org/history/1883-today-the-radical-histor...tball
Fecking SAVAGE article by Tom Humphries in the Irish Times today - I know we're not supposed to "reproduce" the "work" of tHE media but i think a few quotes are appropriate as HE'S SPOT ON!
"Steve Staunton works in a pitiless, well lit world. He chose it for himself. He went from being an assistant manager at Walsall to managing an international soccer team. We don't know how far beyond the business of picking up and laying out training cones his work at Walsall went, but we know this morning that we are watching a man who has tragically overreached himself........
Delaney has linked his administrative career to Staunton's ability to deliver. The national team has become an instrument of political expediency. This grand tradition we all feel intimately acquainted with and passionate about is a plaything.
Steve Staunton shouldn't be left out there dangling. We are watching a snuff movie and it's horribly uncomfortable. The Irish international soccer team is not a learning tool, not a typewriter with the letters on the keys blacked out, not a flight simulator in which you can make 1,000 bumpy landings......."
krossie
Yeah he has to go. But this a chance for the proletariat to flex their muscles. I call for an all out indefinite General Strike to commence on Monday 16 October unless hes gone by then. The proud proletariat will keep their tools downed until Roy Keane is appointed as manager.
Pushkin
Secretary for Inter-Species Solidarity
Vanguard Leninist League
Irish Section
Provisional International Secretariat of the Fourth International (International Centre for Reconstruction)
The moggy has a point though not sure about Keano's manners!!
I doubt he'd be foolish enough to go for the MANAGER job yet - doing too well were he is
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4158/is_200...87212
kp
The workers won't down their tools in Erris, aer lingus and the underfunded hospitals
but fuck it, if Ireland loses a game then there should be a general strike.
Bertie would love it, given his support for manchester.
his connections to manchester.
his love of the game.
In response to the comment about Ireland not having enough dirversity religiously,socially or otherwise, I would just like to make a few points. There is nothing wrong with national pride and it goes without saying that any Irish soccer fan wants to see their team win. Why bother having international soccer tournaments if no one cares which country wins? It makes perfect sense that the Irish team represents the Irish people and nation, the team is'nt there to include everybody and make Ireland a shining example of liberal diversity, it's there to win competitions and do us proud. The team not that is put out should be the best one not the most dirverse, or most politically corect. Why does there need to be a certain number of atheists or homosexuals on the team? Their religion and orientation is irrevelevant. Filling the team out with such people for the sake of promoting equality is ridiculous. If a player who is gay, atheist , black or muslim is good enough to play, he should make the team, otherwise he shouldn't be considered. It's as simple as that. The reason the majority of the team is white, straight etc. is because those are the profiles the majority of the country fall into and it's common sense therefore that the team will in some way represent this. Why is it necessilary important that atheists, or gay people etc. HAVE to be on the team? Including the entire spectrum of society in the national team is not what it's about. It's about getting the best possible team together that is most likely to win when they play. As for lesbians, it would be somewhat difficult on the male national team.
Its always good to see an article criticizing the FAI but as an Irish football fan I know exactly what these imposters get up to. I have been following the Eircom league for years now and we put up with this mob on a weekly basis. I dont really know where to start but I could be here all day telling tales of the FAIs amateurism but unless the people of Ireland demand change nothing will be done
On the pitch we need to start looking closer to home for talent. I have nothing against the likes of Sean Saint Ledger, Andy O'Brien, Nick Colgan, Paul McShane and Alan O'Brien but from what I have seen of them (or havent in Alan O'Briens case) there are players every bit as good playing in Ireland and most of them have European experience. Darren Quigley,Barry Ryan, Darren Kelly, Stephen Paisley, Danny Murphy, Owen Heary, Killian Brennan,Joe Gamble and Roy O'Donovan are just some names that spring to mind. We cannot continue to rely on British clubs to develop players for the national team, we are probably the only country in Europe that do this. Government investment is badly needed and it would also help if the bar stool FA Premier League brigade realised that they can contribute to Irish football by taking in their local clubs games on a regular basis.
As regards merging the FAI & IFA ,why would they agree to this?? They have a young and improving team and I dont recall us looking to merge during our better days.
While Roy O'Donovan, Joe Gamble, Killian Brennan, Owen Heary, Darren Kelly all might be in with a shout, I'm not sure Paisley's euro experience is much to go on about. Being beaten 5-1 by Carmarthen is up there with Cyprus. As a gypsy I won't say too much about 'white lines' Barry Ryan. And I think you might find it hard to get the Cork's Cockney Danny Murphy in unless of course he applies under the parenting rule.
What no Stephen Ward?
Less talk, more betting. You can still get evens on the Czechs online. Bet of the year.
I'm after putting on money for an Irish win but only got 13:5 - crap or what!
Paisley is one of the best centre halfs I have seen this season in the Eircom League. Im also yet to see a better keeper than Barry even though he does have a few black marks against his name ;)
I knew Murphy and Murray were English but I presumed that someone with a name like Danny Murphy had to have an Irish background but no doubt it will never be checked out!
Bohs do have some cracking young players and the reason I didnt mention Ward is because I was looking at positions where I feel Staunton chose players who can be compared to Eircom players.
Anyway may the best team win on Friday (as long as they play in navy)
The General Strike planned for Monday 16 October will proceed. What is required is a new manager under Workers Control. S/he should be paid the average industrial wage and should be subject to immediate recall.
Build for the General Strike!
Be the first to form a Council of Action in your area!
Pushkin
Secretary for Inter-Species Solidarity
Vanguard Leninist League
Irish Section
Provisional International Secretariat of the Fourth International (International Centre for Reconstruction)
I wa s delighted with the performance of the team last night, Wednesday at Lansdown road. The media were ready and posied for the Sack Stuanton mantra, and I would suspect there were many hacks dissappointed with the 1-1 draw against the Checzks.
With time and patience he will build a new team capable of qualifying for the 2010 World Cup. So what if we don't qualify for Euro 2008, altough it may still happen.
Last nights game shows that there is new talent emerging and that when the chips are down they can rise to the occosion.
You'd think that from reading the papers after Cypress that it wa s the end of the world because we lost by such a margin.
Actually that defeat could prove to be a blessing in disguise. From what we witnessed on Wednesday it seems that now is the case.
Prole
Vanguard Leninist League (Workers Power)
Irish Section
Provisional International Secretariat of the Fourth International
(International Centre for Reconstruction/Majority Cadre)
Workers and peasants!
Be warned! The liquidationist wreckers are at work! This MI5/CIA front must be destroyed. Remember Kronstat!
VLLWP
Morozov Branch,
Dublin 4